Differential gene expression turns on salamander attack mode

Hokkaido salamander larva in center with tadpole prey above (Image credit)


The transcriptomics field is boomin’. Approaches like RNA-seq have opened the flood gates to hundreds and hundreds of investigations that compare gene expression between biologically-interesting phenotypes, variants, species, etc.
Plastic phenotypes have been a fascinating area of study for decades in ecology, but the molecular mechanisms behind these phenotypes have only recently become more tractable. A good example of this type of  investigation by Matsunami et al. appears soon in Molecular Ecology:

The main aim of this study was to compare transcriptomic patterns in the brain and peripheral tissues between predator-exposed and prey- exposed larvae of the Hokkaido salamander by using RNA-seq technologies.

Phenotypic plasticity is well documented from both a predator and prey perspectives, and the Hokkaido Salamander is an example of a taxon that displays both types: a super-sized mouth (“attack morph”) when in habitats with large tadpole prey and a suite of traits (large gills, large tail fin; “defense morph”) when in habitats with potential invertebrate predators.


Matsunami et al. show that there were six times more differentially expressed genes among those salamanders that took on the phenotype induced by an invertebrate predator when compared to those that took on the phenotype induced by the presence of tadpole prey (103 vs 605 differentially expressed genes, respectively).
Because the increase in tail height induced by predation pressure is documented in other amphibian lineages, the authors hypothesize that the evolution of a new (plastic) phenotypes probably involves the co-option of pre-existing molecular mechanisms in combination with novel regulation:

In a species already capable of a certain plastic phenotypic response, some molecular mechanisms involved in the expression of pre-existing phenotype may be recruited for the production of the new plastic phenotype. For example, we found that some genes showed similar expression changes in both evolutionarily old predator-induced phenotypes and in evolutionarily newer prey-induced plastic phenotypes. Thus, the co-option and modification of gene networks already used for the expression of evolutionarily old plasticity may occur during the evolution of a novel plastic phenotypic response.

Matsunami M., Kitano J., Kishida O., Michimae H., Miura T. & Nishimura K. (2015). Transcriptome analysis of predator- and prey-induced phenotypic plasticity in the Hokkaido salamander (Hynobius retardatus), Molecular Ecology, n/a-n/a. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/mec.13228

Posted in Molecular Ecology, the journal, transcriptomics | Tagged , | 2 Comments

Another lesson in genomics experimental design and avoiding batch effects

Twitter has been abuzz with Orna Man and Yoav Gilad’s (re)analysis of the data from a recent PNAS paper: “Comparison of the transcriptional landscapes between human and mouse tissues”.
The PNAS paper concluded that the gene expression profiles of different tissues within the same species were more similar than the same tissue across different species. For example, their analysis showed that the gene expression profile of a mouse spleen was more similar to that of a mouse heart than it was to a human spleen. This didn’t seem to mesh with well previous research, so it didn’t make much sense. Well, that is until Man and Gilad decided to probe it a bit further.
Continue reading

Posted in bioinformatics, genomics, next generation sequencing, RNAseq | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

Next generation sequencing: more replicates or more sequence?

Christine Ambrosino http://www.hawaii.edu/fishlab/Nearside.htm

Comic by Christine Ambrosino http://www.hawaii.edu/fishlab/Nearside.htm


The field of evolutionary biology changed drastically with the advent of next generation sequencing technologies. One thing that has stayed the same, however, is the importance of a well-planned experimental design, which ensures the data we collect have the power to answer our questions of interest. We also must still consider budgetary constraints since few (if any) of us have unlimited research funding. With Sanger sequencing, we worried about the number of individuals vs the number of loci to sequence (Felsenstein 2006; Carling and Brumfield 2007) and that question is much the same today- what is the optimal combination of number of samples/replicates/individuals vs sequencing depth per sample for next generation sequencing?
From a transcriptomic perspective, Liu et al. (2014) set out to answer the question of samples vs sequences by explicitly testing the trade-off between increasing biological replicates versus increasing sequencing depth in an effort to detect differentially expressed genes in RNAseq data. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

When genomes duplicate

Whole genome duplication events have played an important role in the evolutionary history of plants.
Vallejo-Marín et al. (2015) describe origins of a new polyploid species, Mimulus peregrines, found on the Scottish mainland as well as the Orkney Islands. It was formed within the last 140 years and corroborated by chromosome counts.


Much of the knowledge about the early evolution of polyploid species stems from young allopolyploid species from four families, but could certainly benefit from the addition of other recent polyploidization events.
In this new Evolution paper, Vallejo-Marín et al. (2015) describe the genome composition of  M. peregrinus and whether it originated multiple times. Using high-depth sequencing, they were able to confirm the parentage of M. peregrinus from a sterile triploid hybrid between two introduced species that are widespread in the UK.

Although the triploid suffers from acute sexual sterility, it is not an evolutionary dead-end. Its ability to propagate via clonal reproduction has allowed this taxon to become part of the ecological landscape of riparian habitats in the UK and from it the fertile allopolyploid M. peregrinus has emerged.

But what about the long term prospects of M. peregrinus? All new allopolyploids have limited genetic diversity, but the multiple origins and rapid genome evolution in M. peregrinus could provide it with the variation that is necessary to be successful.

Whether it will remain a short-lived scientific curiosity [which will eventually be extinct in the wild] or spread well beyond its place of origin … remains to be seen.

References
Vallejo-Marín et al. (2015) Speciation by genome duplication: Repeated origins and genomic composition of the recently formed allopolyploid species Mimulus peregrinus. Evolution 10.1111/evo.12678

Posted in bioinformatics, evolution, genomics, natural history, plants | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Gene flow and Population Fitness

Fitness effects of gene flow (both advantageous and deleterious) have garnered plenty of recent press and scientific exploration. At the population level, the concepts and consequences are notoriously familiar. In the context of immigration, they reduce to existing genetic variation, and new variation introduced into the recipient “sink” population, or conversely, homogenizing effects, and loss of overall biodiversity at the species level. Emigration on the other hand (gene flow to a new environment) could result in local adaptation, and eventual speciation, or loss of genomic diversity due to pervasive inbreeding, and eventual extinction. Three recent manuscripts attempt to summarize/study these concepts, and provide neat springboards for future explorations

  • Genetic rescue to the rescue – Whiteley et al. (2015) TREE

Florida panthers (Puma concolor coryi) – poster mammals for population fitness rebounds due to genetic rescue. Image courtesy: http://intra.burltwpsch.org/users/mfilbert/studentwork06-07/goslin/g12/cub.jpg


Genetic Rescue (GR) can be advantageous to small inbred populations in many ways, due to increased genetic diversity introduced into the “sink” population, often increasing fitness of the population, and its ability to evolve adaptively. But the central debate in the efficacy of genetic rescue lies in whether it delivers on its promise above, or results in what’s known as “outbreeding depression” – the overall reduction of genetic diversity (at the species level), leading to more homogenous populations with reduced diversity. Whiteley et al. (2015) in this excellent TREE review assess numerous studies that have measured population fitness in the context of genetic rescue in several taxa. They also provide an excellent review of the state of the science in utilizing genetic rescue for conservation efforts.

GR may not save imperiled populations over the long term (ultimately, sufficient habitat is required for that), but recent results show that GR can buy time by improving their fitness and increasing population sizes in the short term.
 

Continue reading

Posted in adaptation, evolution, genomics, natural history, population genetics, selection, speciation, theory | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

To review or not to review, that is the question

Imagine this scenario. You are industriously working away on your most recent paper (ignoring other pressing data analyses, administrative duties, and grant proposals). You have just begun to get into the zone of intense focus, writing nirvana, when DING!!! a new email appears in your inbox. It is a request to review a paper from Journal X. You immediately ask yourself: to review or not to review?
Deciding whether to accept or decline a request to review a manuscript is a question that we must all frequently ask ourselves. There are two possible actions to this question: agree to review or decline to review. Furthermore, there are two possible logical outcomes to your reasoning process: sound or faulty. This dilemma can be summarized with a two by two matrix (Figure 1) and I discuss each of these scenarios in turn. Continue reading

Posted in career, peer review, science publishing | 3 Comments

Polyploidy can melt the frozen niche


The rabbit hole of asexual reproduction literature is full of weird detours in the evolution of life.
There are asexual lineages that facultatively have sex, asexuals that still need sperm from other species,  and asexuals that steal sperm from other species, among a whole host of flavors of asexual reproduction. These groups, which can be contemporary to ancient in age, are of significant interest to those studying the origin and maintenance of sex. However, one of the main problems in comparing asexual lineages with closely-related sexual species is that asexuals usually have traits, mainly increased ploidy, that confound inferences about reproductive mode.
An interesting paper in the recent edition of PNAS by Mau et al. investigate one of the only systems where disentangling the effects of reproductive mode and ploidy is even possible, the genus Boechera. These perennial plants include widely-spread sexual diploid species, asexual diploids, and asexual triploids. The authors identify specific alleles associated with the creation of apomictic seeds and use these alleles to distinguish between sexual and asexual specimens from across western North America.
Analyses of this distributional data showed comprehensive niche conservatism between sexual and asexual diploids (“the frozen niche”), but niche differentiation between sexual diploids and polyploids.

Our data provide phylogeographic evidence for multiple origins of apomictic cytotypes in Boechera and support a frozen-niche variation model for diploid apomixis niche evolution. Importantly, we provide statistical evidence that ploidy variation, both within and among species, is a stronger driver of niche evolution than reproductive mode.

This is just one aspect of a more complicated evolutionary history that includes multiple bouts of hybridization and transitions between reproductive modes, but Mau and colleagues provide one of the best recent efforts at understanding the mechanism that makes weird asexuals, well, weird.
Mau M., Lovell J.T., José M. Corral, Christiane Kiefer, Marcus A. Koch, Olawale M. Aliyu & Timothy F. Sharbel (2015). Hybrid apomicts trapped in the ecological niches of their sexual ancestors, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 201423447. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1423447112

Posted in DNA barcoding, natural history, plants | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

The death of the p-value? Probably not.

Image modified from "Death of a Salesman". Image from Wikipedia

Image modified from “Death of a Salesman”. Image from Wikipedia


In February, a social psychology journal, Basic and Applied Social Psychology , made the bold (and extreme) move to ban the use of p-values, F-statistics, T-values, and any other form of Null Hypothesis Testing (NHT) method. This major move generated a lot of buzz in the press and on social media: with some praising the move and others urging that we proceed with caution.
In a recent comment in Nature, Jeffrey Leek and Roger Peng point out this ban is only treating one symptom, while we should really be trying to treat the root cause: problems and errors in judgement during any other stage of experimental design and analysis.
Continue reading

Posted in methods, politics, science publishing | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

Sous les mers: cradles or museums of biodiversity?

While thinking about environmental genomics and writing this post on a recent article in Heredity, I interviewed Eric Pante.

Deep sea octocorals in situ, taken with an ROV between 1000 and 3000 meters depth. Image courtesy of NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, Our Deepwater Backyard: Exploring Atlantic Canyons and Seamounts 2014

Deep sea octocorals in situ, taken with an ROV between 1000 and 3000 meters depth. Image courtesy of NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, Our Deepwater Backyard: Exploring Atlantic Canyons and Seamounts 2014

Posted in adaptation, bioinformatics, Coevolution, evolution, genomics, interview | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Grasping gorgonians

A recent issue of Heredity focused on the brave new world of environmental genomics. After highlighting the special issue, I started chatting to one of the contributors, Eric Pante and became interested in his work on gorgonians.

Deep sea octocorals in situ, taken with an ROV between 1000 and 3000 meters depth. Image courtesy of NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, Our Deepwater Backyard: Exploring Atlantic Canyons and Seamounts 2014

Deep sea octocorals in situ, taken with an ROV between 1000 and 3000 meters depth. Image courtesy of NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, Our Deepwater Backyard: Exploring Atlantic Canyons and Seamounts 2014


Eric and his co-authors explored the extent to which RAD tags can be used to infer phylogeny. This paper arose from a GDR, or Groupement de Recherche (I’ll be posting an interview with Eric to go along with this summary of the Heredity paper, so check back to read more about GDR’s), that facilitated the collaboration of among researchers and labs addressing similar questions.
Continue reading

Posted in bioinformatics, Coevolution, evolution, genomics, mutation, phylogenetics | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment